Head coaches have been a hot topic lately, with several across the league being on varying degrees of hot seats. Despite the high number, though, who might be worried about their job security, all 32 head coaches are the same as they were when the season began. Barring any movement after this week’s games are played, this will be the first time since 2017 that we’ve made it to Thanksgiving with that being the case.
I’m doing something unusual this week, as I’m breaking my article into two pieces. This first half will cover the coaches who have realistic chances of being fired at year’s end, or even before. The second half, which will come out tomorrow (Friday), will discuss those teams and greater length and what direction they might go if they do, in fact, move on from their current coaches.
I’ve broken the coaches I’m discussing today into tiers, based on both if and when their firings are most likely to come. There are 11 coaches who I deemed genuine firing candidates. I assume the other 21 should be expected back in 2027, save for potential retirements, historic collapses, or career-ending scandals.
Might Be Before Season’s End
Coaches whose last games with their teams could be any week for the rest of this season
Aaron Glenn – One of the foregone conclusions of this cycle, Glenn could be gone any day now. The Jets play their next two games against teams who are currently 1-8, and handing those teams each their second victories would likely spell the end for Glenn. That being said, the fan base is already focused on the 2027 Draft and the wealth of early picks this team has, so the need to appease them is less urgent. The team could simply keep him around until season’s end in the hopes of tanking as effectively as possible.
Robert Saleh – The only two occupants of this tier are the current coach of the Jets and the previous coach of the Jets, whose first year as the coach of the Titans has gone quite terribly. With recent reports of Saleh having lost the locker room, coupled with apparent front office concerns about the handling of Cam Ward’s development, it’s easy to see him being fired sooner rather than later as a statement, especially if the team wants to give Ward one more year.
Black Monday Cometh
Coaches whose clocks are simply ticking away until they’re relieved of their duties after Week 18
Shane Steichen – It’s clear that Steichen won’t be back in Indianapolis next year, but I put him here because he wasn’t fired when general manager Chris Ballard was, and it seems they would have pulled the trigger then if they were going to do it in-season. That being said, I can’t rule out the possibility that Carlie Irsay-Gordon would rather wait until the team is mathematically eliminated before a coaching shake-up. But unless that’s the case, I would expect to see his name in a breaking news notification on the morning of “Black Monday,” if not during the Sunday Night Football game of Week 18.
Dan Quinn – The writing seems to be on the wall for Quinn, but there are arguments to be made on both sides. After all, he took a previously-hapless team to the NFC Championship in his first year at the helm, and Jayden Daniels missed most of the second year. On the other hand, two losing seasons in a row and some questionable moments (see: the third column in their record) As such, he might actually spend the hours and days after his season ends still waiting to find out about his fate.
Nick Sirianni – I posited before the season that Sirianni might be let go to pursue better options (more on that tomorrow) even if the Eagles simply lost another Wild Card game. Now that they seem destined to finish with a losing record and in the cellar of the NFC East, it’s almost a sure thing. But once again, they have little reason to not let him finish out the year.
It Just Depends
Coaches who will be gone if they don’t get the one result needed to keep their jobs
Brian Schottenheimer – After a surprisingly favorable early impression as a head coach, albeit one that still came without many wins, things have gone downhill quickly for Schottenheimer. He stayed out of the first listed tier because of the weakness of the NFC East. It seems to be a two-team race now, and the vulnerability of the Giants to their tough remaining schedule will keep the Cowboys alive into January. If they win the division, he’ll obviously keep his job for at least one more year, and probably two. But Jerry Jones will likely get impatient with the lack of change if they fall short.
Todd Bowles – It seemed a few weeks ago like his firing was inevitable, and that it would probably come before Halloween, let alone Thanksgiving. That defense (his specialty) has improved, and the team has played hard to get back into contention in yet another subpar division. For Bowles, the path is as clear-cut as it gets: win the division or lose your job.
Kellen Moore – A similar ultimatum has probably been suggested to Moore, and unfortunately for these two men, this proposition is mutually exclusive, meaning one will be looking for a new job by mid-January. After a last-second loss to the Panthers (who could also take the division and send both Moore and Bowles packing), the Saints are on increasingly thin ice.
Probably Not, But It Could Happen
Coaches whose job security is being questioned by media and fans, but who I think will be safe
Dave Canales – To finish out the run of NFC South coaches featured in this article, I’ll start with Canales here. The argument against keeping him is that if they miss the playoffs, all three of his seasons will have ended with losing records, even if one ended with a playoff berth. But I don’t think he’ll be fired. For one thing, the Panthers do currently have the lead in the division, though a second loss to his former employers in Tampa Bay next Monday would really set them back in their pursuit of a second straight title. For another, I do think he’s highly enough thought of that he’ll be given one more year for the team to take a leap. We’ll see what happens, but I’m ultimately guessing that he stays.
Jim Harbaugh – Just past the midway point of a disastrous season for the Chargers, the assumption by many is that Harbaugh will be let go. However, this team was in a very bad spot when he was hired, and he led them to over-achieve for two straight years before the regression hit them so hard that they quite simply bottomed out. With his proven track record in the NFL and how much he was sought after, I think they’ll opt to keep him a little longer and give him a chance to turn things around in 2027. Coordinator changes will certainly be made, though, on both sides of the ball.
DeMeco Ryans – While things have also bottomed out in Houston (though the current state of the AFC gives them a chance to get back into the race with a serious hot streak), Ryans is also accomplished, having taken the Texans to the playoffs in three straight years to start off his head coaching career. That and his status as a longtime, beloved player for the Texans should buy him some extra time unless the wheels really fall off down the stretch. I’d expect to see him back next year, though he would be on a much hotter seat by then. The talent of this roster does leave them in an open Super Bowl window, though, so we can’t rule out changes being made sooner.
These 11 franchises will be covered in tomorrow’s companion article, with hiring strategies and prospective candidates. These will include some of the men you just read about, among others.
