In yesterday’s article, I outlined 11 coaches who could, and in many cases almost certainly will, see their jobs taken away at the end of the season, if not before. I listed these in tiers based on the likelihood and timing of these potential firings. For today’s exercise, I’m going to assume that all 11 coaches are in fact relieved of their duties, even if the realities of the NFC South make that almost certainly fiction. This will enable all of these coaches to be candidates for the other 10 jobs. Given that they’re being treated with equal likelihood, I’m simply going to go through the teams in alphabetical order rather than maintaining the tiers from yesterday.
Carolina Panthers
While the Panthers are admittedly one of the least likely of these teams to move on, they also make for one of the most interesting hypothetical hiring cycles. The direction of the franchise is unclear because Bryce Young’s place as the franchise quarterback is unclear. He’s continued to show flashes, including late in the game this past Sunday, but has cooled off a bit since his torrid start to the year. Their plan at head coach could be dependent upon their plan at quarterback, which will be discussed more on this site in a few weeks. In their last head coaching search, they ended up with one of the most sought-after young coordinators in the league, and I ultimately think it’s most likely they go back to that well. Specifically, I think the well would be in Jacksonville, Florida, where OC Grant Udinski and DC Anthony Campanile are both hot head coaching candidates ahead of this offseason.
Dallas Cowboys
If Brian Schottenheimer is let go after two years, I expect Jerry Jones and his sons will want someone with NFL head coaching experience to replace him. Given the state of the defense, Brian Flores makes a lot of sense to turn that unit around, particularly with how well a couple of the young pieces on that defense would fit his chaotic scheme. This job would be a good fit for him as well because his greatest problems with the Dolphins came from reported tension while trying to develop a young quarterback. There would be no such problem in Dallas, and Dak Prescott would likely be given a big say in the coordinator hire. A return for Kellen Moore could be in the works there if that’s the case. Other veteran head coaching possibilities include Jim Harbaugh, Mike Tomlin, and Sean McDermott, all of whom would likely welcome the chance to take over a team with a proven quarterback as well. However, speculation about reticence on the part of Jerry Jones to pay top dollar for a head coach does make some of those into tougher propositions if true.
Houston Texans
On the off-chance that DeMeco Ryans is in fact fired, the team is going to strike while the iron’s hot and their roster talent has them firmly in a Super Bowl window. That would make theirs perhaps the most attractive opening and could give them their pick of the litter. All four of the veteran candidates mentioned above for their Texas counterparts are very plausible. One of the top coordinators on the market would as well: Klay Kubiak. Like Ryans, he has deep ties to the Texans, as he was born in Houston and his father was the head coach of the Texans for eight seasons. Additionally, he would bring with him much of the verbiage from San Francisco, which CJ Stroud already knows well from his first two years being coordinated by former 49ers assistant Bobby Slowik.
Indianapolis Colts
This hiring process will be murkier, especially given the Carlie Irsay-Gordon is hiring a coach for the first time. Because of Harbaugh’s time as a player there, he will be discussed in the media as a candidate. But this is a full rebuild with a heavy dose of quarterback purgatory, and I doubt that’s what he’s looking for. Many other candidates may be looking for something more promising, as well. They could go for another stopgap veteran option there, but that approach never worked out for now-former GM Chris Ballard. The tanking route in year one is more likely for them, which means they will probably be making a long-term commitment to a young coach or going stopgap at head coach instead of quarterback, like the Texans a few years ago with David Culley or the 49ers with Jim Tomsula. If that’s the route they go, it’s truly anybody’s guess who they end up hiring. If it is the young coach, one promising option is UCLA head coach Bob Chesney, whose meteoric rise and instant success will have him fielding lucrative offers from around the football world this offseason.
Los Angeles Chargers
I assume the Chargers would prioritize hiring an offensive guru to help turn things around for a quarterback as talented as Justin Herbert. One options who could be appealing to ownership because of his Super Bowl ring is Nick Sirianni. If they’re more interested in a first-time head coach who’s cut his teeth as an offensive coordinator, Udinski will be a candidate for them as well, and so will Kubiak. A couple of others who could be in that mix, and who will be interviewed for several jobs, are Bengals OC Dan Pitcher and Rams OC Nate Scheelhaase, who wouldn’t have to mover very far.
New Orleans Saints
Essentially forced into another rebuild here, the Saints would most likely be looking at the same top young coordinators as everyone else, especially since they don’t offer much to tempt the more accomplished veteran coaches right now. One that would certainly entice them is Kubiak, as I’m guessing they regret having let his brother get away.
New York Jets
The Jets are extremely interesting as a head coach destination, given that they will have three first-round picks this year, putting a quick rebuild very much on the table if the draft picks hit. In this hypothetical in particular, where a former Jets assistant in Schottenheimer is fired by the Cowboys, that means that Dallas missed the playoffs and all three picks are in the top 18. This will be exciting to any candidate. Now, there have been issues, historically, from the top down in this organization. Those could scare off someone like Tomlin, who can likely have almost any job he wants. It might not be too much for someone like McDermott, if they’re looking for someone who has proven he can win games with regularity in the NFL. If not, many of those same coordinators mentioned above will likely end up with this job after fielding interviews from most of the league’s available teams.
Philadelphia Eagles
I expect the Eagles to go for a veteran head coach here. Shane Steichen will be a candidate, especially if Jalen Hurts is expected to be able to continue his career, as Hurts played his best pro football under Steichen. McDermott also used to be with the Eagles, and is thought of highly in that building. And of course, Tomlin has deep Pennsylvania roots and his approach would fit the way the Eagles like to do things. With this roster and this recent pattern of tremendous success, coaches who have done it before will find this job appealing, and the Eagles will be looking for someone who has proven his worth as a head coach to ensure that success continues.
Tampa Bay Buccaneers
To be completely honest, if the Bucs and Panthers do in fact both fail to win the NFC South, Tampa could just turn around and bring back their old OC in Canales. If not, they could also still be feeling the void of Liam Coen, and could bring in one of his current coordinators to get some of that influence back. Flores could also be a candidate if the recent defensive hot streak turns cold again, and they want to focus on that side of the ball in their hiring process.
Tennessee Titans
Whether the Titans decide to give Cam Ward one more year under a new coach or if they draft a quarterback with their almost-certain top 10 pick, they’ll be looking to hire a quarterback developer. There were reports last offseason of interest between the Titans and Texas Longhorns head coach Steve Sarkisian, but nothing materialized or even came especially close. I don’t think it will come together this time, either, and I don’t think that it’s the best fit for any of the involved parties anyway. But it may come up again. While I’ve mention Scheelhaase, and he could be in the running, taking Kliff Kingsbury from the Rams is very plausible for them. Otherwise, of the coordinators discussed, staying in the division and poaching Udinski from Jacksonville feels most likely.
Washington Commanders
They could go any direction with this hire. Experience could be the driving factor, but so could the excitement of youth and upside. As for the expertise of the coach, they could focus on building a better defense or they could opt to prioritize putting Jayden Daniels in the best position to succeed. If anybody hires Ravens OC Declan Doyle, the Commanders seem likely from a schematic trend standpoint. But they could also bring back Kingsbury, who coached Daniels to his Offensive Rookie of the Year performance just two years ago. On the defensive side, only positive things came out of the building this past offseason when they interviewed Flores for their DC position before hiring one of his position coaches. If they go a different direction, but stay on the defensive side, Campanile is the most likely hire.
